In the face of rampant commoditization, businesses are often caught in a trap where their products or services become indistinguishable from competitors', leading to a price war. The traditional solution, differentiation, soon becomes ineffective as competitors quickly match any unique features. A more effective strategy involves understanding the specific type of commodity trap in your industry, and then devising a business strategy to not only escape the trap but also leverage it for future growth. This involves six steps: identifying what customers are willing to pay for, pinpointing your differentiating factors, investing resources wisely, developing a unique brand identity, conveying your personal and company value to the customer, and making your expertise more visible. By following these steps, businesses can escape the commoditization trap and position themselves for future growth.
-Recognize the predicament: When a new low-end competitor enters the market offering a basic version of a product at a much lower price, it disrupts the existing market dynamics. These competitors usually benefit from economies of scale, making it hard for established companies to match their prices. Consequently, customers become hesitant to pay extra for value-added services like superior service or expertise. Attempts by existing companies to lower prices and reduce product features lead to decreased margins but often fail to prevent market share loss. This situation poses a challenge as direct competition with these entrants can further fragment the market and lower industry revenues. -Detect the predicament early To counteract market deterioration and the influence of dominant discounters, companies can adopt strategies that focus on quality over price, targeting customers who prioritize and are willing to pay for quality, thus maintaining margins and avoiding price wars. Publicizing low operational costs can deter competitors from initiating price cuts. Additionally, companies can leverage idle capacity as a threat to flood the market with low-priced goods if necessary, preventing competitors from reducing prices. These tactics help companies manage market power and maintain profitability in the face of aggressive discounting. -Evade the predicament In response to competition from dominant discounters, businesses can adopt strategies like moving upscale, focusing on superior products that justify higher prices. This involves investing in features that enhance product quality, as seen with Italian silk makers who co-invested in advanced silk-making technology. Alternatively, businesses can change their channels, time, or place to avoid direct competition, like Procter & Gamble did with a new pet food brand. Companies can also shift focus to other markets, as Intel and Armani did, or introduce new products for growing market segments, like Wrigley's sugar-free gum brands. These strategies help businesses sidestep competitors and tap into new opportunities. -Annihilate the predicament Businesses facing competition from discounters adopt various strategies to retain market share. Some simplify products to cut costs, while others, like Armani, enhance exclusivity through private pre-release sales, now a major revenue source. High-end fashion brands sell pre-owned goods, and companies like General Electric focus on lower total ownership costs to outdo cheaper rivals. Adobe distributes free software to boost sales of complementary products. Similarly, consultants and wholesale clubs like BJ's and Costco shift from traditional pricing to performance-based fees or membership models, keeping product prices competitive. These tactics redefine customer value and adjust pricing perceptions to maintain competitiveness. -Exploit the predicament to your benefit Responding strategically to discounters can be rewarding. One approach is to reinvent the supply chain to maintain profitability while offering lower prices. This could involve simplifying product design or implementing cost-cutting measures. Another strategy is to redefine customer value perception. For example, Armani began offering private showings to manufacturers and retailers, enhancing exclusivity and boosting revenues. Changing customer pricing perceptions is also effective. General Electric competes against lower-priced rivals by ensuring its total life-cycle costs are lower. Companies like Adobe offer products for free and generate revenue through usage fees or ancillary products. As competition erodes uniqueness, innovation becomes crucial. -Select the appropriate strategy When confronting a deterioration trap, companies can turn it to their advantage by differentiating their offerings or moving upmarket. Target countered Wal-Mart by focusing on design, while Costco and BJ’s used membership fees for lower prices on bulk items. Krogers competed with Wal-Mart in groceries with lower prices and better service. Microsoft's inclusion of security software in its OS forced competitors to offer superior service. Gillette moved upmarket with advanced razors like Sensor, Mach3, and Fusion, limiting BIC’s market share. The choice to fight or flee a commodity trap depends on a company's resources relative to its competitor's.
book.moreChapters
